ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

LLOYD OMDAHL: The oil industry comes at great cost

North Dakota is on a euphoric high, with the oil industry pouring billions of dollars into the state treasury, mineral owners' pockets and business ledgers. Western towns once written off as dead have sprung back to life.

Omdahl
Lloyd Omdahl

North Dakota is on a euphoric high, with the oil industry pouring billions of dollars into the state treasury, mineral owners' pockets and business ledgers. Western towns once written off as dead have sprung back to life.

The state has gained world-wide importance, on course to churn out a million barrels a day, passing up all other oil-rich states except Texas.

While the Bakken boom has been heady for this blank spot on the map (as once described by native son Eric Sevareid), state policymakers need to keep their heads and not let gratitude trample their perspective of what is happening on the ground.

While the new money is fabulous, so are the costs of dealing with the impact of the Bakken. Here is a quick summary of the costs to the state, local governments and private citizens.

At one point, Stanley, N.D., School Superintendent Kent Hjelsmstad estimated that schools in northwestern North Dakota needed $200 million to cope with the influx of over new students -- with more on the way.

ADVERTISEMENT

Forecasting a population increase to 7,500, Watford City, N.D., officials are looking at an expected cost if $400 million to expand public services and facilities.

The 2013 session of the Legislature appropriated $1.5 billion in general funds for new highway construction and expenses, three-fourths of which is going to oil-affected areas of the state.

Attorney General Wayne Stenehjem has stressed the significant increase in drug crime, meaning more money desperately is needed for law enforcement. McKenzie County, N.D., has been forced to hire a full-time state's attorney to handle the new prosecutions brought by the oil boom.

Emergency medical crews are being taxed beyond their limits. The agencies involved in medical services in the Oil Patch reported an increase of 60 percent over the past five years, and they predict that it will reach 150 percent in 2014-15.

Oil field waste now is more than 500,000 tons a year, meaning that new costs are occurring for the State Health Department, whose job it is to monitor oil and chemical spills.

Dave Glatt, head of the department's environmental section, noted that "the environment as we know it is not going to be the same." That cost cannot be quantified in dollars.

But the costs related to the Bakken are not confined to the public sector. Private citizens -- especially those who were residents before big oil -- have been paying as well.

The most dramatic impact has been the cost of housing. The market has become so competitive that rents of $2,500 a month for two-bedroom apartments are not uncommon.

ADVERTISEMENT

One senior confronted with this tripling of rent explained that "we are all on fixed incomes, living mostly on Social Security, so it's been a terrible shock." (God bless the memory of Franklin Roosevelt.)

An area policymaker underlined the problem by noting that "grandma can't go to work in the oil fields and make 150 grand a year."

Other folks suffering from the oil boom are the landowners who did not own the mineral rights under their fields and now are being trampled by the development with very little, if any, benefit.

Actually, there are so many untallied costs involved that it will be years before we can quantify the impact on the state, its local governments and private citizens.

So, while we revel in the new money and the population growth, we need to balance these benefits against the costs.

And right now, the cost-benefit ratio is not as good as it looks on the surface.

Next week: The oil industry is getting off cheap.

What To Read Next