We see that you have javascript disabled. Please enable javascript and refresh the page to continue reading local news. If you feel you have received this message in error, please contact the customer support team at 1-833-248-7801.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Port: Wouldn't it be nice if political leaders respected both immigrants and the need for border security?

Believe it or not, it's possible to acknowledge that migrants crossing our borders illegally are engaged in a proud American tradition — how many of our ancestors were immigrants seeking safety and prosperity for their families? — while simultaneously believing that immigration ought to be regulated and orderly.

Migrants cross the border in Yuma, Arizona
Migrants seeking asylum in the U.S., mostly from Venezuela, stand near the border fence while waiting to be processed by the U.S. border patrol after crossing the border from Mexico at Yuma, Arizona, on Jan. 23, 2022.
Go Nakamura / Reuters
We are part of The Trust Project.

MINOT, N.D. — The largely unserious demagogues who, at least nominally, are our leaders at the national level have been locked in a bit of political theater over illegal immigration.

Border states with Republican leadership like Texas, Arizona, and Florida, the loci of our struggles with illegal immigration, have begun ostentatiously shipping illegal immigrants from their communities to liberal enclaves like New York and Martha's Vineyard.

In doing so, these Republican leaders have been calling the liberals on their "sanctuary cities" bluff. Turns out, when illegal immigrants turn up en masse, as they do in communities along the border, our liberal friends are less sanguine about the situation.

There was a big show of volunteerism in the liberal communities, but that's an easy thing to do when the crisis has lasted merely days, as opposed to the decades citizens in places like El Paso and Yuma have had to deal with the fallout from lax border enforcement.

In making this point this way, the Republican leaders have resorted to using the immigrants — human beings who are just looking for a better lot to live — like theater puppets, and that's not great. We also have reports that some of the immigrants were perhaps tricked into getting on buses, or boarding flights, and that's even worse.

ADVERTISEMENT

Though, to be fair, it's not just Republican governors doing this.

The mayor of El Paso, a Democrat, and his city council, which is controlled by Democrats, have also been putting illegal immigrants on buses . Apparently, their partisan affiliation has inoculated them against accusations of cruelty from their fellow Democrats.

MORE FROM ROB PORT
This strategy playing nice with lunatics will eventually blow up and start costing Republicans elections.
On this episode of Plain Talk, activists for and against a term limits proposal weigh in.
In a better sort of world, where politicians and activists and social media rubberneckers were capable of a modicum of empathy and rational thought, we might have waited for facts that might support the conclusion before turning Ellingson's death into a political talking point. Sadly, we don't live in that world.
This is a situation that deserves better than the hot takes we're getting from Twitter demagogues and cable news creeps.
"I'm not smoking any pot," Dooley said on this episode of Plain Talk, which featured a debate between the two candidates. "He's actually accomplished what he says he's accomplished," adding that he's even gotten permission from Goehring to hunt on his land.

Also, the federal government has been engaged in a de facto busing scheme, too. In a phenomenon called "catch-and-bus," migrants detained at the border often get a permission slip to travel into the country, at which point they hook up with a volunteer organization that gets them bus tickets where they want to go.

Nobody really had a problem with this until Republicans started doing it to make a point that was inconvenient for Democrats.

But as the politicians act out their soap opera, those of us more concerned with solving problems than dunking on the political opposition might be wondering why our leaders can't treat illegal immigrants with kindness and dignity while also pursuing strong border policies.

Believe it or not, it's possible to acknowledge that migrants crossing our borders illegally are engaged in a proud American tradition — how many of our ancestors were immigrants seeking safety and prosperity for their families? — while simultaneously believing that immigration ought to be regulated and orderly.

We've been duped by the politicians and the cable news shouters and the professional activists into believing our choices, when it comes to the illegal immigration problem, are either a nativist opposition to immigration or completely open borders.

This is absurd.

ADVERTISEMENT

There is a way to humanely secure our borders. What we need are political leaders who prioritize that goal over the sort of dramatic political combat that makes good fodder for Twitter posts and cable news segments.

Opinion by Rob Port
Rob Port is a news reporter, columnist, and podcast host for the Forum News Service. He has an extensive background in investigations and public records. He has covered political events in North Dakota and the upper Midwest for two decades. Reach him at rport@forumcomm.com. Click here to subscribe to his Plain Talk podcast.
What to read next
It's hard to overstate how bringing chip-making to this country is good for this country. It would not only create many thousands of American jobs; it would ensure that other U.S. manufacturers don't have to beg Asians for semiconductors.
InForum columnist Jim Shaw argues it's high time for North Dakota to legalize marijuana. "I have never smoked marijuana, and don’t encourage it," Shaw writes. "However, the time has come for North Dakota, like 19 other states and Washington, D.C. to legalize it, regulate it and bring in millions of dollars in taxes."
We need to be able to work our way through this.
“Train children in the right way, and when old, they will not stray.” Say thank you to those mentors who shaped who you are today.