ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Froma Harrop: Don't ever go soft on crime

It's a safe assumption that fear of crime is what flipped several suburban New York congressional districts to Republicans.

Froma Harrop
Froma Harrop
We are part of The Trust Project.

It was always surprising to hear voices on the fringe left downplay the COVID-era spike in crime. Still more amazing, though, were the grown-ups in the Democratic Party who seemed to be giving them a sympathetic listen.

More politics
"I believe if we're able to get to an agreement, we could have a funding agreement for the next two years," McCarthy said.

Kathy Hochul should have been able to easily put away Lee Zeldin in the New York governor's race. Zeldin was not one of those civilized Republicans whom Northeast voters often elect on the state level. He came out of the feral Trump wing of the Republican Party, peddling lies about a stolen election. Hochul won but should not have sweated so much, especially in a state where Democrats hold a 2-1 registration advantage over Republicans.

But crime was a big issue there as elsewhere, and Hochul had refused to oppose part of a 2020 bail reform law being blamed for a number of heinous crimes. New York Mayor Eric Adams was hotly critical of the controversial provision, which made it hard for judges to keep repeat offenders deemed dangerous locked up before trial.

The public shuddered at headlines like "Homeless man shoves stranger to her death in Times Square subway station" (Daily News) and then read that the "oft-arrested" individual had "a documented history of mental issues."

It matters not that the right exaggerates the extent of criminal violence in New York, while ignoring far worse numbers in red America. (The city's murder rate is a third that of Miami's.) Nor that an analysis of police statistics finds the likelihood of falling victim to a violent crime on the subway to be about the same as getting injured in a crash after driving only two miles.

ADVERTISEMENT

Adams would not endorse Zeldin because of his lack of interest in stemming the flood of guns onto America's streets — which the former police captain ascribed for the spike in murders. Who could feel safe in a culture where people pull out firearms over parking places and loud music, and deranged individuals can easily carry semi-automatics?

From 2017 through 2021, 87 people died in Texas just from road rage shootings versus 15 in New York state. In that same five-year period, killings on the New York subways in totaled 18.

Yes, crime has risen since the pandemic though the wave seems to be breaking. Murder in New York City is down 14% so far this year. In the bad year of 2021, the city's homicide rate was still less than a fifth what it was in the very bad year of 1990.

Fox News likes to portray the Democratic stronghold of New York as the epicenter of criminal depravity. That's one reason why registered voters give Republicans a 20-point advantage over Democrats on ability to handle crime.

But then you had Alvin Bragg, the Manhattan district attorney who rightfully came under fire for saying he would stop prosecuting low-level crimes and jail only those accused of the most serious offenses -- which, according to him, did not necessarily include robbery and assault. Of course, the horrific crimes get the most attention, but a law enforcement official must never ever say that certain crimes will be ignored by his office.
And if you dig deeper into what unsettles New Yorkers, it is the frequent lower-level crimes -- shoplifting, car break-ins, motorcycles on sidewalks -- that leave a sense of general disorder. It bothers many that the cough medicine aisle at drug stores is now locked up.

It's a safe assumption that fear of crime is what flipped several suburban New York congressional districts to Republicans. The fears may not match the reality, but elected officials should not add fuel to them with careless talk. Kathy Hochul was lucky this time.

Froma Harrop is a nationally syndicated columnist whose work is regularly published in the Grand Forks. Herald.

Related Topics: GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS
Froma Harrop covers the waterfront of politics, economics and culture with an unconventional approach. She takes public policy quite seriously. Herself, less so.


What To Read Next
"Life is short, ends in a moment, and we don’t think much about it some days. ... It’s a scenic highway, and we should keep it that way, go a bit slower, and enjoy life."
"Some of Fargo's leaders would have us believe they're fighting gun violence. But they're not. They're wasting our time fighting over something that wasn't a problem in the first place."
It's hard to rock across North Dakota while the state Legislature is in session, according to columnist Tony Bender.
"North Dakota's lawmakers could help reduce property insurance premiums, and take away some upward pressure on property taxes, by giving the state's fire departments back their full funding."