Sponsored By
An organization or individual has paid for the creation of this work but did not approve or review it.



NW Minnesota legislator sees problems in smoke-free economic impact report

Smoke-free ordinances caused little or no effect on restaurant and bar sales in Minnesota, a new report released this week said. The report, given to lawmakers, comes as the Minnesota Legislature grapples with a proposed statewide smoking ban in ...

Smoke-free ordinances caused little or no effect on restaurant and bar sales in Minnesota, a new report released this week said. The report, given to lawmakers, comes as the Minnesota Legislature grapples with a proposed statewide smoking ban in bars, restaurants and workplaces.

The report, released Monday by ClearWay Minnesota, the successor to the tobacco settlement-funded Minnesota Partnership for Action Against Tobacco, includes Beltrami County as one of three counties and four cities with smoking ordinances studied.

"There was no apparent economic impact as a result of the Beltrami County smoke-free ordinance, which was effective on Jan. 1, 2005," the study notes.

The report viewed aggregate data of population, sales and eating and drinking establishments and jobs from 1994 through 2005, and was conducted by the Minnesota Institute of Public Health and sponsored by ClearWay Minnesota.

At least one legislator casts doubt on the report, naming a list of Beltrami County establishments that lost business after the county's smoke-free ban was put in place.


The report gives a county average that includes establishments in the city of Bemidji, Sen. Rod Skoe, DFL-Clearbrook, said Monday as the report was presented to the Senate Business, Industry and Jobs Committee. It then applies the data "as if there is no economic impact, but it appears to me the smoking ban kind of picks some winners and losers in the food and beverage industry."

The report shows aggregate sales for eating and drinking establishments in Beltrami County from 1994 to 2005 increased by 54.3 percent to $44.9 million, an average annual increase of about 4.9 percent. Adjusted for inflation, the trend appears flat over the period.

From 2004 to 2005, the increase in aggregate sales was $1.02 million, or 2.5 percent.

The figures, however, only reflect one year - 2005 - under a smoke-free ban, which was modified to allow smoking in bars and restaurants from 8 p.m. to 3 a.m. A full ban took effect last month.

The study shows the aggregate per capita sales in Beltrami County eating and drinking establishments was $709 for 2005, a slight decrease from $733 in 1994 in a trend that over the years bounced from a high of $733 to a low of about $580 in 1996. The trend, however, for the past three years, including one under the smoke-free ordinance, shows a slight rise.

It also showed the number of employees in eating and drinking establishments in the county growing by 11.7 percent from 1994 to 2005, and the number of eating and drinking establishments up by 12 percent during the period. While the trend dipped slightly in the early 2000s, it has been steadily increasing the past three years.

The more than 80 eating and drinking establishments in 2005 is the highest since 1994, and the number of employees at about 1,300 is about equal with the mid-1990s.

Skoe, however, questioned the data, saying more than a few county bars and restaurants have lost business since the county enacted its smoking ban.


"While the county average might be OK, there certainly have been winners and losers within the mix," Skoe said. A business in Waskish lost $46,000, down 17 percent in food sales and down 29 percent in liquor sales, he said. "During the time when the walleye season was opened up, they should have been having an increase."

And, "other bars near Bemidji (have) sales down," Skoe said, citing one with $78,000 in lost revenues and laying off people, a Tenstrike establishment having sales down 40 percent and going from two full-time workers to three part time, a Turtle River establishment down 35 percent in revenues and the Turtle Creek Saloon down 38 percent.

"The Bemidji Legion is down $10,000 a month," Skoe said. "Gambling receipts are down from $2.8 million to $1.3 million."

Also in Bemidji, Skoe said Keg 'N Cork lost $56,000 in gross revenues in 2005, but got $18,000 of that back in 2006. "Lost customers no longer patronize their business."

Sen. Ron Latz, DFL-St. Louis Park, a bill co-sponsor, said nationwide statistics show a business affected by a smoking ban will lose revenues in the short-term, but a year or more later will gain it back.

The Pioneer in Bemidji is a newspaper of Forum Communications Co., which also owns the Herald.

What To Read Next
Josh Sipes was watching an in-flight movie when he became aware the flight crew were asking for help assisting a woman who was experiencing a medical problem.
Nonprofit hospitals are required to provide free or discounted care, also known as charity care; yet eligibility and application requirements vary across hospitals. Could you qualify? We found out.
Crisis pregnancy centers received almost $3 million in taxpayer funds in 2022. Soon, sharing only medically accurate information could be a prerequisite for funding.
The Grand Forks Blue Zones Project, which hopes to make Grand Forks not just a healthier city but a closer community, is hosting an event on Saturday, Jan. 21, at the Empire Arts Center from 3-5 p.m.