ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Judge denies legal challenge to Public Service Commission campaign contributions

BISMARCK - A federal judge has ruled against two environmental groups that sought to strip North Dakota of its authority to regulate the coal mining industry because they claimed that campaign contributions to state officials violated federal law.

We are part of The Trust Project.

BISMARCK - A federal judge has ruled against two environmental groups that sought to strip North Dakota of its authority to regulate the coal mining industry because they claimed that campaign contributions to state officials violated federal law.

The Dacotah Chapter of the Sierra Club and the Dakota Resource Council asserted that donations from people affiliated with coal companies to the campaigns of two North Dakota Public Service Commission members violated a conflict-of-interest provision in federal law.

In his ruling filed today, U.S. District Court Judge Daniel Hovland concluded that "the authority to undertake an enforcement action of the state program is discretionary and unreviewable," and as such, the federal court lacks jurisdiction in the matter.

However, he added in a footnote: "This order should in no manner be construed as an endorsement of the practice of PSC Commissioners accepting campaign contributions from individuals or political action committees closely associated with coal companies and coal mining activities.

"Although the acceptance of campaign contributions from such entities may be lawful ... the decision to do so is ill-advised, devoid of common sense, and raises legitimate questions as to the appearance of impropriety," Hovland wrote.

ADVERTISEMENT

Hovland heard arguments in August in the case filed in May 2012 by the environmental groups against the U.S. Secretary of the Interior in federal court in Bismarck.

The lawsuit asked the judge to compel Secretary of the Interior Sally Jewell to withdraw approval of North Dakota's surface mining program until it was brought into full compliance with the federal Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977.

The act allows states to assume responsibility for regulating coal mining as long as their regulations are at least as stringent as federal regulations. North Dakota began regulating coal mining operations in the state in 1983.

The Sierra Club claimed that thousands of dollars in campaign contributions to North Dakota Public Service Commissioners Brian Kalk and Kevin Cramer violated the federal act. But Hovland wrote that by providing states the exclusive regulatory control through enforcement of their own approved laws, Congress intended that the federal law establishing minimum standards would "drop out" as the operative law and leave it in the hands of states.

"To construe SMCRA in the manner urged by the Plaintiffs would circumvent the carefully designed balance Congress established between the federal government and the states," Hovland wrote. "... If the Plaintiffs wished to challenge the enacted state program, the appropriate time for doing so has now long passed."

Hovland granted summary judgment in favor of Jewell and the PSC, which intervened in the lawsuit and sought to have it dismissed, and denied summary judgment for the Sierra Club.

What to read next
Sound and electrical stimulation may offer hope for people suffering from chronic pain and other conditions. Researchers are exploring the combination with the goal of developing treatments that are safer and more accessible than opioid medication. Viv Williams has details of a new study in this episode of NewsMD's "Health Fusion."
When those first baby teeth appear, it's time to start teaching little ones about good dental health. In this episode of NewsMD's "Health Fusion," Viv Williams consults a pediatric dentist about when kids should have their first dental appointment and she shares tips on brushing.
Long road trips provide ample time for both reflection and rumination — the good and the bad of hours and hours spent behind the wheel. In this Health Fusion column, Viv Williams shares stories of a recent drive to Colorado and how a pit stop at a botanical garden's butterfly house made a faulty air conditioner tolerable and brought meaning to the buzz word "mindfulness."
When you sprain your ankle or have an infection inflammation helps to heal tissues. But when inflammation is chronic, or long term, it can contribute to conditions such as heart disease and autoimmune diseases. Researchers have found a link between chronic inflammation and low levels of vitamin D. Viv Williams has details in this episode of NewsMD's "Health Fusion."