Republican candidates for governor take aim at Walz during Mankato debate

It was the first time in the campaign that the candidates have publicly debated, but their comments focused more on the DFL governor than on one another.

Republican candidates for Minnesota governor participated in a debate in Mankato on Wednesday, Nov. 3, 2021. They are pictured in a screenshot of a live stream video here.
We are part of The Trust Project.

ST. PAUL — Minnesota Republicans vying for the state's GOP endorsement on Wednesday, Nov. 3, faced off for the first time at Minnesota State University at Mankato. And in their first foray, the five candidates took more swipes at Gov. Tim Walz than at one another.

Former Senate Majority Leader Paul Gazelka, former state Sen. Scott Jensen, Lexington Mayor Mike Murphy, dermatologist Neil Shah and entrepreneur Mike Marti each used their time in the hour-and-a-half debate to put down the first-term Democratic-Farmer-Labor governor for his response to the COVID-19 pandemic, civil unrest following George Floyd's murder and DFL legislative priorities.

And they said that on the heels of a Republican win in Virginia and near-flip in New Jersey, they were hopeful that a GOP candidate could take the Minnesota governor's office in 2022. Sen. Michelle Benson, who is also running for governor, could not attend the debate due to a scheduling conflict.

"Wow the Democrats got a whooping last night," Murphy said. "We saw that in Virginia and we can do that in Minnesota. We just have to pick the candidate that can take on the tyrant Tim Walz."



  • Unable to agree, Minnesota working group punts $250 million hero pay decision to Legislature After meeting more than a dozen times, the group closed out without reaching a compromise. The result puts the decision to the divided Legislature to determine how the state should send out the funds to front-line workers.

  • Minnesota starts vaccination effort for children ages 5-11 The state has also launched a website to help parents find vaccines for children

  • Local leaders press Minnesota lawmakers for housing options in cities where 'there is simply none available' Greater Minnesota county officials asked legislators for additional tools to draw in developers as they struggled to put up enough new homes to house area workers.

Taking aim at the administration's stay-at-home orders and mask mandates, Jensen and Gazelka said the state's COVID-19 response had been too extreme and they would've trusted people to make decisions to limit the virus' spread.
“Those are a one-size-fits-all approach and it doesn’t work,” Jensen, a physician who has been flagged for spreading false information about the coronavirus, said. And Gazelka told the audience that he would've attempted to lead by giving people information and a choice to make rather than a stick.

“You don’t lead with a stick, you lead with influence and help people be informed to do the right thing,” Gazelka said.

The candidates shared many ideas around limiting taxes, boosting law enforcement staffing, ensuring second amendment rights and taking a more lax approach to the COVID-19 pandemic. But a couple seemed to criticize those who'd previously held elected office for not doing enough to push conservative policies.

"Career politicians in St. Paul won't stand up for gun rights," Shah said. "While the House is under Democratic control, they continue to pass anti-gun bills, where is the Senate passing pro-gun legislation?"

Gazelka pointed to his experience leading the Minnesota Senate and said it would be an asset if elected, as it meant he could govern. And he tried to dispel the "career politician" monicker.

"The person you should be looking for is somebody who already knows how to govern," he told attendees. "We can't just have somebody who gets 45% and does same old, same old; we need somebody who knows how to build bigger and broader bridges."

Walz has said he'll seek reelection for a second term in 2022. And on Wednesday, he told reporters at the Mall of America vaccine clinic that he remained focused on the state's rollout of COVID-19 immunizations to children 5-11, as well as other efforts to respond to the pandemic.

“I was elected to do the job here in Minnesota. I don’t spend a lot of time watching what other races do,” the governor said. “The people of Minnesota over the next year, they’ll decide where they’re at. I’ll keep focusing on the things that matter, and right now, it’s this.”


Alliance for a Better Minnesota, a progressive advocacy group, following the debate said the Republicans continued to "peddle the same empty promises and dangerous ideas" on pandemic response and public health.

Follow Dana Ferguson on Twitter @bydanaferguson , call 651-290-0707 or email

Dana Ferguson is a Minnesota Capitol Correspondent for Forum News Service. Ferguson has covered state government and political stories since she joined the news service in 2018, reporting on the state's response to the COVID-19 pandemic, the divided Statehouse and the 2020 election.
What to read next
Monday's unanimous ruling is the latest dismissal of a push from the Minnesota Voters Alliance to change the makeup and procedures around absentee ballot boards, which must accept or reject absentee ballots. It's part of an effort from conservatives nationally to change the way absentee ballots are handled.
It wasn't the biggest fire in recent history in northern Minnesota. The Pagami Creek Fire in 2011 was nearly four times bigger and scorched a huge swath of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness.
The vote among 15,000 Minnesota Nurses Association members was "overwhelmingly" in favor of the strike, according to MNA.
Daniel Thomas Nelson, 25, Hopkins, was fishing on Elm Island Lake when he fell overboard and never resurfaced.