US Steel's Minntac water permit reversed

In a consolidated set of appeals, the Minnesota Court of Appeals reversed the MPCA's decision to issue a water permit to U.S. Steel.

Part of U.S. Steel's Minntac facility in Mountain Iron seen in 2015. (Forum News Service file photo)
We are part of The Trust Project.

DULUTH -- The Minnesota Court of Appeals is reversing a decision that granted U.S. Steel a permit for continued operation of its Minntac taconite tailings basin in Mountain Iron.

The appeals court found that the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, which issued the permit to U.S. Steel, failed in its interpretation of state water-quality rules and that the MPCA's decision on tailings discharge was unsupported.

Now, the permit decision heads back to the MPCA for further proceedings and review.

In a statement, the MPCA shared that it assessing next steps.

"The Minnesota Pollution Control Agency is dedicated to protecting Minnesota’s most valuable resource — its water," the statement read. "The MPCA will continue engaging with stakeholders to ensure the state’s groundwater and surface water are protected.”


The decision was part of a consolidated set of appeals, including those filed individually by U.S. Steel, WaterLegacy and the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa.

Paula Maccabee, advocacy director and counsel for WaterLegacy, said the decision was an "important first step to set limits on sulfate pollution and protect Minnesota surface waters."

Like the MPCA, WaterLegacy is still reviewing the decision and determining what its next steps are.

The appeals court also decided that the state can't enforce groundwater standards. The Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy said that decision "handed mining companies a win."

Aaron Klemz, director of public engagement for the Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy, wrote in a statement: "The mining industry takes advantage of unclear standards and loopholes to gut our ability to protect Minnesota’s water. With even more dangerous sulfide mines proposed for Minnesota, today’s decision shows the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency either cannot or will not effectively protect Minnesotans from mining pollution."

U.S. Steel did not return a request for comment by the time of publication.

What to read next
Thief River Falls Regional Airport closing in on 40-year high in passenger count
Calgary, Alberta-based TC is widely known for its Keystone oil pipeline, a critical artery for moving Canadian oil to U.S. refiners that dominated headlines over the past decade for an expansion that ultimately failed. But moving natural gas around the United States, Canada and Mexico is the bigger part of TC's business.
According to recent business surveys completed by the Red River Regional Council, the region will need upwards of 1,000 new employees in manufacturing, healthcare, education and small businesses over the next five years. The goal of the new initiative is to address this need by creating a marketing strategy to promote rural northeastern North Dakota as a quality place to live, work and play.
The grand opening celebration, which will have special offers for customers, will be held Friday, Dec. 9, with a ribbon cutting ceremony set to be held at 10 a.m.